Earrings

Discover our stunning collection of earrings for everyday wear, featuring handmade earrings in whimsical, fantasy, bohemian, and gothic designs. Each pair is artisan-crafted with polymer clay, beads, crystals, and mixed media—creating unique earrings that are lightweight, comfortable, and perfect for daily wear or special occasions.

From delicate stud earrings and cute polymer clay earrings to dramatic butterfly wing earrings, dangle drop earrings, and statement beaded designs, our handmade earrings collection offers something for every style. Whether you're searching for fairy earrings, celestial studs, boho dangle earrings, or unique handmade earrings that express your personality, you'll find artisan-crafted treasures with hypoallergenic posts and lightweight comfort.

Perfect for women who love fantasy, nature-inspired, and whimsical jewelry. Every pair is handcrafted with care and creativity. Free US standard shipping over $100 with code FREESHIP100. Gift wrap available.

83 products

 Fairy & Butterfly Wing Earrings FAQs 

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I choose between stud and dangle earrings?

Choose studs if you prefer earrings that sit close to your ears and work easily with scarves or high necklines. Dangle earrings add movement and show more of the design. Check the measurements in each listing and compare them with a pair you already enjoy wearing.

Are your handmade earrings lightweight?

Yes! Most of my earrings are lightweight, including my hand-beaded earrings, polymer clay designs, and butterfly wing earrings. You can enjoy detailed beadwork, sculpted shapes, or fluttering wings without a heavy feel. Check the individual listing for details about your chosen pair.

Do you offer nickel-free earrings?

Yes! Many of my handmade earrings have nickel-free ear wires or posts, and selected designs offer a 925 sterling silver ear-wire upgrade. Materials vary by design, so check the individual listing before ordering. If you have a known metal sensitivity, choose a metal you already wear comfortably.

Can I buy your handmade earrings without pierced ears?

Yes! Selected butterfly designs are available as clip-on earrings, with silicone comfort pads and information about a YouTube tutorial for adjusting the fit. Many of my other dangle earrings can also be converted to clip-ons. Email me at paula@paulamcnulty.com with the design you’re interested in before ordering.

How can I tell how long the earrings will look on me?

Check the measurements in the product description and compare them with earrings you already own. You can also hold a ruler beside your ear to estimate where the design will fall. If you’re unsure whether a measurement includes the ear hook, email me at paula@paulamcnulty.com before ordering.

Do you offer dangle earrings for stretched ears?

Yes! Selected butterfly wing designs are available with stainless steel ear tunnels for stretched ears. Use the Ear Gauges filter to find them, then check the available sizes in the product listing before ordering.

Can I send handmade earrings directly as a gift?

Yes! Enter your recipient’s shipping address at checkout. Gift wrapping is available for $4.99 per order and includes a silver butterfly organza pouch, silver tissue paper, and a handcrafted personalized gift tag. During the holidays, I use a snowflake organza pouch with silver tissue paper.