Handcrafted Art jewelry for Fairy Lovers, Cosplayers & Fantasy Fans

Shop by Category

View all
1 10
View all

Butterfly Wing Earrings

A collection of the lightest, prettiest fairy wing earrings. Whether you are going for an earthy fairy grunge look or an ethereal aesthetic, you will find the perfect earrings for your style.

1 3
View all

  • Hi! I'm Paula — the artist behind every piece at Paula McNulty Designs. Each item is handcrafted in my New York workshop especially for you.

  • All fantasy jewelry, hair accessories and gifts are made to order just for you – no mass production, ever. When you shop here, you're getting a one-of-a-kind piece you won’t find anywhere else.

  • From concept to final detail, I sculpt or bead each design by hand — so what you receive is truly one of a kind and made with intention.
Learn More

Cosplay Crowns

1 4
View all

Shop by Theme

1 5

Bead Embroidered Gothic Choker


Evoke vintage romance and shadowed elegance with this one-of-a-kind hand-beaded lace choker—designed to enchant with every glance.

Shop Now

Loved by Fantasy Fans Like You

  • ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

    "LOVE the necklace!

    I needed a necklace for a Ren Faire outfit and this was perfect. Very well made, delivered quickly and in pretty packaging that would be great as a gift too. I have a feeling I’ll be asked where I found my necklace and I’ll be happy to share." - Bill

  • ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

    "Amazing workmanship.

    I would highly recommend seller. Thank you for your amazing work." - Hope

  • ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

    "I LOVE THESE EARRINGS!!! I tried them on before work (Not allowed to wear any earrings at work) and seriously did NOT want to take them off. They are absolutely fabulous! Nice and light weight, length accentuates the neck. Whimsical and beautiful through and through.” -Elizabeth
More Testimonials
polymer clay hair sticks

Enchanting Hair Wands

Create spellbinding hair styles every day with enchanting hair wands.

Shop the Magic

Fantasy Dragons

1 3
View all
Eight colorful bead embroidery pendants with handmade polymer clay art textured center focals.

Beaded Jewelry

Exquisite handcrafted beaded artisan jewelry designs created with bead embroidery and bead...

Beaded Jewelry

owl jewelry brooch

Owl Jewelry Pin

Owl Jewelry Pin

$92.00 USD
$92.00 USD
Gold sleeping sun face pendant with orange and green seed bead edging.

Sun and Moon Jewelry

Unique sun and moon jewelry and hair accessories handcrafted with celestial inspiration,...

Sun and Moon Jewelry

Blog Posts

View all
1 3
View all